Scam Prevention

Stolen Car Detection 2025: How to Verify a Vehicle Isn't Stolen

AutoHunter Research TeamDecember 27, 202511 min read
VIN check on vehicle dashboard
TL;DR|The Bottom Line
  • Run free NICB VINCheck before any purchase
  • VIN should match on dashboard, door jamb, and title
  • Be wary of deals too good to be true
  • Buying stolen = losing the car AND your money
  • Title in seller's name is essential

Cars Stolen/Year

750,000+

Up

Recovery Rate

56%

Stable

Avg. Buyer Loss

$12,500

Up

VIN Clone Rate

8%

Up

The Stolen Vehicle Risk

Over 750,000 vehicles are stolen annually in the United States. Many end up for sale to unsuspecting buyers. If you purchase a stolen vehicle—even unknowingly—you will lose both the car and the money you paid.

Verification Steps

1. NICB VINCheck

The National Insurance Crime Bureau offers free VIN checks at nicb.org. This database includes vehicles reported stolen and those with salvage or total loss records. Run every VIN before meeting a seller.

2. Physical VIN Verification

Check the VIN in multiple locations: dashboard (visible through windshield), driver's door jamb sticker, and engine block. All should match exactly. Any discrepancy indicates potential fraud.

3. Title Verification

The title should be in the seller's name. Jump titles (blank or third-party names) are red flags. Verify the VIN on the title matches the vehicle. Check for signs of tampering or alteration.

Warning Signs

  • Price significantly below market value
  • Seller rushing the sale or creating urgency
  • No title or "title in the mail"
  • Damaged ignition or door locks
  • Seller can't answer questions about vehicle history
  • Meeting in unusual locations
  • VIN stickers that appear replaced or tampered
BUY

Verify Before You Buy

Pros

  • Free NICB check takes seconds
  • Physical VIN check is straightforward
  • Prevention avoids total loss

Cons

  • VIN cloning can fool basic checks
  • No protection if you buy stolen
  • Some verification requires expertise

Recommendation

Always run NICB VINCheck, verify VINs match physically, and ensure the seller has a clean title in their name. If anything seems wrong, walk away. The risk of buying stolen isn't worth any deal.

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Articles