Is OfferUp safe for buying cars?

Safer than Craigslist, comparable to Facebook Marketplace. TruYou verification (ID verification badge) adds layer of seller accountability. Built-in messaging creates paper trail. Still requires all standard precautions.

What is TruYou verification?

OfferUp's identity verification process. Sellers verify their ID with a driver's license scan. Look for the TruYou badge on seller profiles—verified sellers are significantly less likely to be scammers.

How does OfferUp compare to Facebook Marketplace?

OfferUp has smaller inventory but growing. Prices similar (OfferUp slightly higher). TruYou offers better verification than FB profiles. FB Messenger is more widely used for communication.

Does OfferUp have buyer protection for cars?

No. OfferUp Buyer Protection only covers shipped items under $10,000. In-person car transactions have no platform protection. Standard private sale caution applies.

OfferUp Cars 2025: Complete Buying Guide & Safety Tips | AutoHunter

OfferUp: The Growing Third Option

OfferUp has quietly grown into a significant player in local car sales, especially on the West Coast and Texas. It sits between Craigslist (anonymous, lower prices, more scams) and Facebook Marketplace (social profiles, most inventory) with its own unique strengths.

The TruYou verification system is OfferUp's key differentiator. Sellers who verify their identity with a driver's license get a badge on their profile. This doesn't guarantee honesty, but it creates accountability that Craigslist lacks.

TruYou Matters

Always check for the TruYou badge before responding to car listings. Verified sellers have submitted government ID. Scammers rarely complete this verification.

Platform Strengths

Identity verification: TruYou badge indicates ID-verified seller
In-app messaging: All conversations recorded, useful if disputes arise
Profile ratings: See seller's transaction history and reviews
Clean interface: Better search and filter than Craigslist
Community safety: Report bad actors easily

Platform Weaknesses

Smaller inventory: Less selection than FB Marketplace
Regional variance: Strong in some areas, sparse in others
No buyer protection: Cars are in-person transactions with no recourse
Lower response rates: 58% vs 73% on Facebook

Pricing Comparison

OfferUp pricing lands between Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace:

Craigslist: -12 to -14% vs market (lowest but riskiest)
OfferUp: -6% vs market (middle ground)
FB Marketplace: -8% vs market (most inventory)

The slightly higher prices on OfferUp reflect somewhat safer environment and slightly more serious sellers.

Safety Protocol

Only respond to TruYou-verified sellers
Check seller's rating and transaction history
Keep all communication in OfferUp app (creates record)
Run VIN check before meeting
Meet at public location (police station ideal)
Verify seller's ID matches title owner
Pay only with verified funds (cash at bank, verified check)

Outside App = Red Flag

If a seller wants to move conversation to text, email, or WhatsApp, be suspicious. Scammers avoid OfferUp's in-app messaging because it creates evidence trail.

Negotiation Tips

OfferUp's "Make Offer" button makes price negotiation easy. Start 8-10% below listing price. Sellers on OfferUp tend to be slightly less aggressive negotiators than Craigslist sellers—54% success rate vs 71% on CL.

Your message should convey: ready to act quickly, have done research, flexible on timing. Example: "Interested at $X. I'm free this afternoon if you want a serious buyer with cash."

WATCH

Solid Third Option

Pros

TruYou verification adds safety layer
Clean app interface
Growing inventory
In-app messaging creates records
Profile ratings help vet sellers
Less crowded than FB Marketplace

Cons

Smaller inventory than FB
No buyer protection
Regional availability varies
Lower response rates
Slightly higher prices than CL

Recommendation

OfferUp is worth monitoring alongside Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist. The TruYou verification offers meaningful safety improvement over Craigslist. Best for West Coast and Texas buyers. Use AutoHunter to monitor all platforms simultaneously.

Frequently Asked Questions

Search All Platforms with AutoHunter

AutoHunter monitors OfferUp, Facebook, Craigslist, and more—alerting you to deals across all platforms.

Start Free Trial

Flipper Guide

Facebook Marketplace Car Buying Guide

Buyer Guide

Craigslist Car Buying Guide