OfferUp Cars: The Complete Buying Guide
Everything you need to know about buying cars on OfferUp safely
- OfferUp is the third-largest car marketplace after Facebook and Craigslist
- TruYou verification helps identify legitimate sellers - look for the badge
- Lower volume means less competition but also fewer deals
- Cash offers and quick pickups are key differentiators for buyers
- Scam rate is similar to other platforms - use same safety protocols
- Best for finding local deals in metro areas - limited rural inventory
Market Share
~15%
UpAvg Response Time
2-4 hours
StableTruYou Verification
60% of sellers
UpAvg Savings vs FB
3-5%
StableOfferUp: The Third Marketplace
OfferUp is the third-largest car marketplace in the US, trailing Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist. Its smaller size means less inventory but also less competition for deals. The TruYou verification system adds a layer of accountability missing from other platforms.
For flippers and buyers, OfferUp is worth monitoring alongside the bigger platforms. Sellers sometimes list here after getting lowballed on Facebook, and may be more motivated to deal.
OfferUp vs Other Platforms
| Feature | OfferUp | Facebook Marketplace | Craigslist |
|---|---|---|---|
| Inventory Volume | Medium | Highest | Medium-High |
| Seller Verification | TruYou (good) | Profile-based | None |
| In-App Messaging | Excellent | Good | Email only |
| Buyer Protection | Limited | Limited | None |
| Scam Rate | Medium | Medium | Higher |
| Price Negotiation | Easy | Easy | Easy |
Understanding TruYou Verification
TruYou is OfferUp's identity verification system:
- Phone verification: Confirms active phone number
- Facebook link: Connects to established Facebook profile
- ID verification: Submits government ID for confirmation
TruYou doesn't guarantee a seller is honest, but it creates accountability. Verified sellers are less likely to attempt scams because their real identity is on file.
TruYou Priority
When choosing between similar vehicles, prioritize TruYou-verified sellers. The verification process weeds out many scammers. However, unverified sellers can still be legitimate - just apply extra caution.
Safety Protocols for OfferUp
| Safety Step | Why It Matters | How to Implement |
|---|---|---|
| Check TruYou Badge | Verified identity reduces scam risk | Look for badge on seller profile |
| Meet at Safe Location | Prevents robbery and assault | Police station, bank parking lot |
| Daylight Inspection | See condition clearly | Schedule viewings before 4pm |
| Bring Companion | Witness and safety backup | Friend or family member |
| Cash Handling | Prevent counterfeit and robbery | Count at bank, bring exact amount |
Red Flags to Watch For
- No TruYou badge + new account: Higher scam risk
- Price far below market: If it's too good to be true, it is
- Refuses in-person meeting: Legitimate sellers want to sell
- Mentions shipping or escrow: Classic scam indicators
- Pressure to pay quickly: Creates urgency to prevent thinking
- Limited or vague photos: Hiding problems or using stock images
How to Find Deals on OfferUp
Search Strategy
- Set up saved searches for target vehicles
- Enable notifications for new listings
- Check multiple radius options (sellers may list nearby cities)
- Sort by "Newest" to catch fresh listings
Negotiation Tactics
- Use "Make Offer" for initial low offers (saves time on uninterested sellers)
- Follow up rejected offers with messaging and justification
- Mention cash and same-day pickup capability
- Ask about flexibility if listing has been up for 2+ weeks
Cash Safety
Never show large amounts of cash until you're ready to complete the transaction. Count money at your bank before meeting. Bring exact purchase amount in a sealed envelope. Complete cash exchange inside a bank if possible.
Completing the Transaction
Documentation Checklist
- Seller signs title properly (no errors, all fields complete)
- Get bill of sale with both parties' information
- Photograph seller's ID and title together
- Verify VIN matches title and door jamb sticker
- Get seller's contact information for follow-up questions
Payment Methods
- Cash: Preferred for private sales, immediate and final
- Cashier's check: Acceptable but verify at issuing bank first
- Venmo/PayPal: Not recommended for vehicles - no buyer protection
- Wire transfer: Never for private party sales
OfferUp is a worthwhile addition to your car search.
OfferUp offers TruYou verification that other platforms lack, and less competition can mean better deals. Use it alongside Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist. Apply the same safety protocols as any online marketplace - meet publicly, verify identity, inspect thoroughly, and pay safely.
Pros
- TruYou verification adds accountability
- Less competition than Facebook Marketplace
- Good in-app messaging system
- Easy offer and negotiation features
Cons
- Lower inventory than major platforms
- Limited rural/suburban coverage
- Scams still exist despite verification
- No built-in payment protection for vehicles
Recommendation
Add OfferUp to your daily marketplace monitoring routine. Prioritize TruYou-verified sellers and apply the same safety protocols as other platforms. The smaller market can yield less competition for good deals.
Frequently Asked Questions
Monitor All Marketplaces With AutoHunter
AutoHunter tracks cars across Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist, and OfferUp so you never miss a deal.
Start Free Trial