What's the best opening message for car negotiations?

Keep it simple and professional: "Hi, I'm interested in your [Year Make Model]. Is it still available? I can come see it [specific day/time]." This shows serious intent without tipping your hand. Avoid asking about lowest price in first message—it signals you're a tire-kicker or looking to lowball.

When should I make my first offer?

Never make an offer before seeing the car in person. During messaging, focus on scheduling the viewing. After inspection, point out specific issues you observed: "I noticed the brake pads are worn and there's a chip in the windshield. I'd be interested at $X considering these repairs I'll need to make."

How do I handle sellers who won't negotiate?

Many sellers who say "firm" will negotiate given the right approach. Wait 3-5 days and follow up: "Still thinking about your car. Would you consider $X if I can pick up today?" Time and cash convenience often unlock flexibility. If still firm and overpriced, walk away—there are always more cars.

Should I mention I'm paying cash?

Only during final negotiation, not in initial messages. Mentioning cash early invites scammers or reduces leverage. During in-person negotiation: "I have cash with me and can close today if we can agree on $X." This creates urgency and convenience value—sellers often accept 5-8% less for immediate certainty.

Facebook Marketplace Car Negotiation 2025: Scripts That Close Deals

The Psychology of Private Seller Negotiation

Facebook Marketplace sellers are emotionally attached to their vehicles. They believe their car is worth more than market value because they know its history and have cared for it. Effective negotiation acknowledges this while using objective data to establish fair pricing.

The goal isn't to "win" or embarrass the seller—it's to find mutual agreement. Aggressive lowballing wastes everyone's time and burns bridges. Professional, respectful negotiation builds rapport that closes deals at fair prices.

The Opening Message

Your first message sets the tone. Keep it brief, professional, and actionable:

Proven Opening Script

'Hi [Name], I'm interested in your [Year Make Model]. Is it still available? I'm available [Saturday morning / tomorrow after 5pm] to come see it. Let me know what works for you.' This shows serious intent, respects their time, and moves toward action.

What NOT to Say in Your Opening

"What's your lowest price?" — Signals tire-kicker
"Would you take $X?" — Lowball without seeing car = instant rejection
"Is there anything wrong with it?" — Implies distrust
Multiple questions at once — Overwhelming and easy to ignore

The In-Person Inspection

Most negotiation happens face-to-face. Arrive on time, be professional, and conduct a thorough but efficient inspection. Your demeanor during inspection sets up negotiation success.

Building Rapport First

Before inspecting, spend 2-3 minutes in conversation. Ask about their ownership experience: "How has it been for you? Any issues I should know about?" Sellers open up when they feel heard. This information becomes negotiation leverage.

Documenting Issues

Take photos of every issue—worn tires, scratches, dents, wear items. Do this openly; don't be sneaky. Say: "I like to document everything for my records." These photos become objective evidence during negotiation.

The Negotiation Conversation

After Test Drive: The Pivot

After the test drive, express genuine interest while pivoting to price: "The car drives well. I'm interested, but I need to factor in some things I noticed. Can we talk about price?"

Presenting Your Case

Reference specific observations: "I noticed the brake pads are getting low—that's $250-$300 I'll need to spend soon. The tires have maybe 10,000 miles left, another $400-$600. And there's the scratch on the rear quarter panel. I'd feel comfortable at $X, which accounts for these repairs."

The Golden Rule

Never insult the car. Say 'I noticed...' not 'This thing needs...' Sellers are attached to their vehicles. Criticism feels personal. Factual observation feels professional. Same information, completely different reception.

Handling Resistance

When sellers push back, don't argue. Acknowledge their position: "I understand you've taken good care of it. I'm just working with what I can afford while accounting for the repairs I'll need."

The Walk

If negotiation stalls, use the walk strategically: "I appreciate your time. I can't quite make the numbers work at that price. Here's my number if you reconsider—I can pick up anytime if we can meet closer to $X."

65% of sellers call back within 48 hours after a polite walk. The car sits there, other buyers flake, and your serious interest becomes more valuable. Don't bluff—only walk if you'll truly let it go.

Closing the Deal

The Cash Close

When you reach agreement: "I have cash with me. Can we handle the paperwork now?" Immediacy prevents seller's remorse and eliminates risk of them taking other offers. Always verify title is clean and matches seller's ID.

Paperwork Checklist

Signed title with date and odometer reading
Bill of sale (both parties sign)
Photo of seller's driver's license
All keys, remotes, and owner's manual
Maintenance records if available

WATCH

Negotiation is a Skill You Can Master

Pros

12-18% average savings with proper technique
Builds relationships for future deals
Data-driven approach removes emotion
Cash convenience creates leverage
Walking away often brings better offers

Cons

Requires practice and patience
Not every seller will negotiate
In-person time investment required
Must be prepared to walk away

Recommendation

Approach every negotiation professionally and respectfully. Use objective data—comparable listings, repair costs, market values—rather than emotional appeals. Be genuinely willing to walk away. Most important: practice. Your first few negotiations will be uncomfortable. By your tenth, you'll be consistently saving 15% or more on every purchase.

Frequently Asked Questions

Flipper Guides

Flip Cars on Facebook Marketplace 2025