Is the 2019 Nissan Frontier reliable?

Yes—extremely reliable. The 2019 Frontier's VQ40DE V6 has been in production since 2005 with millions of trouble-free miles. By 2019, Nissan had resolved all early issues. The 5-speed automatic is equally proven. Owners regularly report 200,000+ miles with basic maintenance. It's one of the most reliable used trucks available.

Why is the Frontier so cheap compared to Tacoma?

The 2019 Frontier was the final year of a design dating to 2005. While mechanically excellent, the interior, tech, and fuel economy lagged competitors significantly. Toyota's brand premium and the Tacoma's more modern platform command 20-30% higher prices. For buyers prioritizing reliability over amenities, this gap is an opportunity.

Should I get the PRO-4X or regular SV?

For off-road use, PRO-4X is worth the premium. Its Bilstein shocks, electronic locking rear differential, and skid plates transform capability. For pavement duty and occasional light trails, the SV 4x4 offers 90% of the capability at $4,000-$6,000 less. The SV's standard suspension is adequate for most buyers.

What are common 2019 Frontier problems?

Issues to watch: Early production timing chain tensioner wear (check service records), radiator/transmission cooler failure causing transmission damage (critical—verify replacement), and premature fuel sending unit failure. The interior is dated and prone to squeaks. These are minor compared to overall drivetrain reliability.

2019 Nissan Frontier Buyer's Guide: S vs SV vs PRO-4X

The Value Play in Midsize Trucks

The 2019 Nissan Frontier is an anachronism—a truck that prioritizes mechanical simplicity over modern features. While competitors packed in touchscreens and turbocharged engines, Nissan kept the proven 4.0L V6 and 5-speed automatic. The result is a truck that will outlast most modern rivals at a fraction of the price.

We analyzed 685 listings to determine fair market values. The Frontier typically sells for 25-35% less than equivalent Tacomas despite similar reliability. For buyers who can overlook the dated interior and basic tech, this represents one of the used market's best values.

Critical: Check Radiator Replacement

Early Frontiers had a design flaw where the radiator-integrated transmission cooler could fail, mixing coolant with transmission fluid and destroying the transmission. By 2019, most have been addressed, but ALWAYS verify the radiator has been replaced or is the revised design. This is a deal-breaker inspection item.

Trim Breakdown

2019 Nissan Frontier Trim Comparison
Feature	S	SV	SL	PRO-4X
Price Range	$14-18K	$18-23K	$22-26K	$23-28K
Engine Options	4-cyl/V6	V6	V6	V6
4WD Available	✓	✓	✓	Standard
Locking Rear Diff	✗	✗	✗	✓
Bilstein Shocks	✗	✗	✗	✓
Leather Seats	✗	✗	✓	✓
Navigation	✗	✗	✓	Optional
Crew Cab Available	✓	✓	✓	✓
Best For	Work	Daily	Luxury	Off-Road

Pricing Analysis

2019 Nissan Frontier Market Price Distribution

Based on 685 active listings nationwide, December 2025

Reliability Data

2019 Nissan Frontier Reliability by Component

Based on 2,400+ owner reports

WATCH

Best Value Midsize Truck

Pros

Proven 4.0L V6 with 200,000+ mile track record
Significantly cheaper than Tacoma
Simple mechanicals mean cheap repairs
PRO-4X is capable off-roader
Strong towing capacity for the class

Cons

Interior is dated and low-quality
Fuel economy lags modern competitors
Tech features are basic
Ride quality rougher than rivals

Recommendation

The 2019 Frontier SV Crew Cab 4x4 with 55,000-70,000 miles at $20,000-$23,000 is the sweet spot. Verify radiator replacement history, check for timing chain noise, and accept the dated interior. You're buying mechanical durability, not modern amenities. For work trucks and budget-conscious buyers, nothing beats this value.

Frequently Asked Questions

Model Guides

2018 Toyota Tacoma: The Premium Alternative

Flipper Guides

Best Midsize Trucks for Flipping in 2025