2015 Toyota Highlander Buyer's Guide: The Family SUV Sweet Spot

Why the 2015 Highlander?

The 2015 Toyota Highlander represents the second year of Toyota's third-generation midsize SUV—a design that continued through 2019 with only minor updates. This generation brought significant improvements: a more refined interior, better fuel economy, improved handling, and the continuation of Toyota's legendary reliability.

Ten years later, the 2015 Highlander remains one of the most sensible used family SUV choices. Depreciation has brought prices to the $18,000-$25,000 range for nice examples, while reliability means these vehicles have decades of service life remaining. For families wanting space, safety, and dependability without new car prices, the 2015 Highlander delivers.

Trim Level Comparison

XLE: The Sweet Spot

For most buyers, the XLE trim offers the best value. Standard features include the reliable 3.5L V6, leather seating, power driver seat, dual-zone automatic climate control, moonroof, and upgraded Entune audio with navigation. The XLE provides comfort and features without the significant price premium of Limited trims.

Look for XLE models with the optional second-row captain's chairs (easier third-row access) and the towing package if you'll pull trailers. AWD is recommended for northern climates but not essential in mild weather areas.

Limited: Luxury Features

The Limited trim adds premium features: perforated leather upholstery, JBL premium audio, larger 19-inch wheels, LED daytime running lights, and additional safety features. The Limited Platinum adds panoramic moonroof, premium interior trim, and rear-seat entertainment screens.

Limited models command $3,000-$5,000 premiums over XLE. The upgrade is worthwhile if you value the specific features, but XLE provides 90% of the experience at meaningful savings.

What to Inspect

Transmission Feel

Some 2015 Highlanders exhibit transmission hesitation at low speeds—a brief delay when accelerating from stops. This was addressed with software updates. During test drive, note any hesitation or hunting between gears. If present, a dealer can perform the TSB update. This isn't a serious problem, just an annoyance that's fixable.

Infotainment System

The Entune infotainment system in 2015 models can exhibit freezing or slow response. Test all functions during inspection: radio, Bluetooth connection, navigation (if equipped), and backup camera. Updates improved stability. Replacement head units are available if the original system is problematic.

Oil Consumption

Some Toyota V6 engines from this era consume oil between changes. Check the oil level during inspection—it should be near the full mark. Ask the seller about oil consumption patterns. Consumption of up to 1 quart per 3,000 miles is considered acceptable by Toyota. Higher consumption warrants concern.

Climate Control

Test both front and rear climate control zones. The Highlander has separate rear controls, and AC issues in the rear system are occasionally reported. Both zones should blow cold air. Repair costs for rear AC can be significant.

Ownership Costs

The 2015 Highlander is economical to own:

• Fuel Economy: 19 city/25 highway (V6 AWD). Real-world average: 21-23 MPG.
• Insurance: Average rates for a family SUV. Shop quotes.
• Maintenance: Standard Toyota maintenance schedule. Oil changes every 5,000-10,000 miles depending on driving conditions.
• Common Repairs: Brakes ($300-$500 per axle), water pump (~$500 if needed), transmission fluid change ($150-$250).
• Tires: 245/55R19 (Limited) or 245/60R18 (others). Budget $600-$900 for quality replacements.

Safety Features

The 2015 Highlander earned 5-star overall NHTSA safety ratings. Standard safety features include: 8 airbags, stability control, traction control, anti-lock brakes, and backup camera. Higher trims add blind spot monitoring, rear cross-traffic alert, and parking sensors.

Note: Toyota Safety Sense (automatic emergency braking, lane departure warning, adaptive cruise) wasn't available until 2017. If these features are important, consider newer model years.